Get Phones Out of School. Unless There’s a Reason They Need to Be There.
Phone-free schools don’t have to treat every use of a smartphone the same. What research and real-world school policies can teach us about distraction, utility and intentional technology use.
Across the country, schools are drawing a harder line around student phone use. This is for a good reason…
A 2025 study published in JAMA Pediatrics used passive sensing to measure adolescents' actual smartphone behavior during the school day. The average phone use for students was 90 minutes each day and the primary use was social media. The researchers also acknowledged that phones can provide benefits for communication and learning, though their findings show that much of the observed school-day phone use appeared inconsistent with those purposes. JAMA Network
Read the JAMA Pediatrics study: Adolescent Smartphone Use During School Hours
And that isn't the only study finding significant phone use during school. A separate 2025 JAMA Network Open study objectively measured smartphone engagement among U.S. youth during the school day, adding to a growing body of research examining not just whether students have phones at school, but how they're actually using them. JAMA Network
Through our work with schools across the country, we've had some particularly interesting conversations with educators about what phone-free learning environments should actually look like.
The goal is clear: remove the distractions that compete for students' attention. But what we've learned is that schools don't necessarily want to eliminate every useful function of a smartphone.
Many of the schools we work with have bell-to-bell or similarly restrictive phone policies. Yet even within those policies, there are thoughtful exceptions.
Medical and accessibility needs are often the most obvious. But we're also seeing educators identify specific academic tools that serve a meaningful purpose, including situations where using a phone may be more practical than opening a laptop.
These conversations have reinforced something important for us at The Commons: phone-free doesn't have to mean technology-free.
And parents are thinking about these distinctions, too.
In a 2024 national survey, the National Parents Union found that 56% of parents favored allowing students to retain access to their phones during the school day with reasonable limits, including opportunities for teacher-approved academic use.
More recently, its September 2026 survey found that 78% of parents supported requiring smartphones to include a built-in School Mode that allows schools to limit distractions.
These findings don't mean parents want more screen time in classrooms. They suggest support for an approach that establishes clear boundaries while recognizing that technology can serve different purposes.
The question isn't simply whether a phone is allowed. It's what students can access, when, and why.
And the distinction between intentional technology use and digital distraction deserves more attention.
Schools have several ways to implement phone-free policies, from physical phone pouches to software-based solutions. For a closer look at the options, read our guide to the best apps and solutions for limiting student phone use at school
Thirty minutes isn't always thirty minutes
Imagine two teenagers each spend 30 minutes on their phones tonight.
One spends those 30 minutes FaceTiming a grandparent who lives across the country, talking with a parent traveling for work or connecting with a relative recovering in the hospital.
The other plans to start homework, opens a social media app for a minute and, 30 minutes later, is still scrolling a personalized feed.
The screen-time report records the same thing:
30 minutes.
But those aren't the same experiences.
One may strengthen a meaningful relationship. The other may have displaced homework, sleep, family conversation or simply something the teenager actually intended to be doing.
This isn't an argument that one particular app or activity is always good or another is always bad.
It's an argument that context, content and purpose matter.
And research increasingly supports looking beyond minutes alone.
Researchers at the Oxford Internet Institute have repeatedly challenged simplistic conclusions that more time with digital technology automatically equals worse well-being. In a study of nearly 12,000 U.S. children ages 9 to 12, Oxford-led researchers found no evidence over the two-year study period that screen time negatively affected cognitive functioning or well-being. Other Oxford research analyzing more than two million people across 168 countries found little evidence that internet adoption itself was associated with widespread deterioration in psychological well-being. Oxford Internet Institute
Explore Oxford Internet Institute's research on teens and screens
That doesn't mean all digital experiences are harmless.
It means “screen time” is an incredibly broad category.
And that's where newer pediatric guidance becomes especially interesting.
The American Academy of Pediatrics' 2026 technical report argues that the traditional idea of screen time captures only one part of children's digital lives. Instead, the AAP describes a broader digital ecosystem that includes algorithms, social media, apps, games, devices and the design choices that shape how children interact with them. American Academy of Pediatrics
The American Psychological Association makes a similar distinction. Its health advisory says social media isn't inherently beneficial or harmful to young people. Outcomes vary based on the individual adolescent, their circumstances and the specific content, features and functions they encounter. American Psychological Association
In other words, the question can't only be: How many minutes were you on a screen?
We also have to ask:
What were you doing there? Why were you doing it? And what was that technology designed to make you do next?
Some technology is designed to be hard to put down
This is where the distinction becomes particularly important for schools.
Opening a graphing calculator and opening an algorithmically personalized social media feed may happen on the same piece of hardware.
But they are fundamentally different digital experiences.
The American Academy of Pediatrics specifically identifies features such as autoplay, infinite scrolling and personalized algorithmic recommendations that can prolong device use and make disengagement more difficult. The AAP notes that this can be particularly challenging for children, who are still developing impulse control. American Academy of Pediatrics
Its accompanying policy statement also calls attention to notifications that can interrupt school or sleep and to engagement-oriented design intended to encourage prolonged viewing. American Academy of Pediatrics
The APA similarly identifies features including recommended content, likes, unrestricted time limits and endless scrolling as important considerations when evaluating social media use among adolescents. American Psychological Association
That's fundamentally different from a student opening an application because a teacher has asked them to accomplish a specific task.
One experience has an endpoint. Another may be intentionally designed not to.
And that's why we don't think every minute on a phone should automatically be treated as equivalent.
To be clear: we're not advocating for more screens in schools
Quite the opposite.
We believe students deserve learning environments where their attention isn't constantly competing with social media, games, streaming, notifications, and other digital distractions.
We also believe schools should be able to establish the boundaries that make sense for their students.
For some schools, that means a highly restrictive approach where nearly all applications are unavailable during the school day, with exceptions for essential communication, medical needs, and accessibility accommodations.
For others, it means maintaining those strong boundaries while allowing a small number of approved educational tools that support specific instructional needs.
The Commons is designed to support both approaches.
Our technology helps schools restrict distracting applications during designated school conditions while preserving the access they've intentionally approved.
The goal isn't to create more opportunities for students to be on their phones. It's to ensure that when technology serves a legitimate purpose, schools don't have to open the door to every other distraction along with it.
The goal isn't more screen time. It's intentional use.
What Apps Should Students Be Allowed to Use in Phone-Free Schools?
Even with restrictive phone policies, schools may choose to allow specific apps for medical needs, accessibility, communication, or educational purposes. The Commons gives administrators the flexibility to determine which tools remain accessible during the school day.
Working with schools across the country has given us a unique window into how educators balance restrictive phone policies with intentional technology use.
Through The Commons, schools can choose to restrict nearly all applications during the school day, with exceptions for essential communication, medical needs, and accessibility accommodations. Other schools choose to preserve access to specific educational tools that support their teaching practices.
What's been particularly interesting is learning about the academic applications teachers are actually using and why access to those tools matters in their classrooms.
Here are a few real examples we've encountered through our work with schools.
Managing a medical condition
Students may need access to medical applications, including tools such as Dexcom for continuous glucose monitoring.
In that context, a smartphone isn't functioning as entertainment. It's part of a student's health-management system.
Finding the next class
Some schools have schedules that vary by day, rotation or period.
Students have told us that during a passing period, quickly checking a schedule on the device already in their pocket can be far more practical than opening a laptop simply to figure out where they're supposed to go next.
Graphing an equation
Desmos gives students access to a powerful graphing calculator on the same device.
For a math teacher who intentionally wants students using that tool, the smartphone can function as a calculator rather than a gateway to everything else competing for the student's attention.
Exploring the natural world
One of the schools we work with uses Seek by iNaturalist, an app that allows students to identify plants, animals, fungi, and other organisms using their phone's camera.
It's a great example of how a smartphone can support hands-on learning rather than replace it. Instead of simply reading about the natural world, students can use technology to explore what's directly around them.
Practicing jazz
We've also worked with a music teacher who uses iReal Pro, an app that provides chord charts, backing tracks, and other tools for practicing music.
For that teacher, the app serves a specific instructional purpose. Allowing access isn't about encouraging more screen time. It's about preserving a tool that supports how students learn and practice music.
These aren't simply hypothetical examples of how smartphones could be used in education. They're the kinds of tools and instructional needs we're encountering through our work with real schools.
And what we've found interesting is that schools aren't necessarily asking for more technology in the classroom. They're asking how to preserve access to tools that already serve a purpose while removing the distractions that come with the same device.
That's the distinction: not more screen time, but more intentional use of technology when it genuinely supports learning.
Can Phone-Free School Policies Allow Medical and Educational Exceptions?
Yes. A phone-free school policy does not necessarily mean students lose access to every function of their devices. Schools can establish restrictions on distracting apps while making exceptions for medical needs, accessibility, communication, and approved educational activities.
For example, a student managing diabetes may need access to a continuous glucose monitoring app, while another student may require an approved accessibility tool. Schools may also choose to permit specific educational apps when they support classroom instruction.
The key is ensuring that exceptions are intentional, clearly communicated, and consistent with school policy and applicable requirements.
Strong boundaries can actually make intentional use easier
There's a paradox here.
When everything on a student's phone is available, asking them to use one thing intentionally also gives them access to everything else.
Open your phone to check today's schedule.
There's a notification.
Open your phone for the graphing calculator.
Instagram is two taps away.
Take out your camera for a science activity.
A message arrives.
The educational tool and the distraction occupy the same device.
That's a difficult environment in which to ask adolescents to continually exercise perfect self-control.
But if we remove the constant competition for attention:
The phone can simply become a calculator.
A field guide.
A musical tool.
A schedule.
A medical device.
A way to call home.
And when that purpose is over, it can go back into a backpack or pocket.
That's a very different way to engage with technology.
Phone-free should create space for digital literacy, not replace it
Strong boundaries and digital literacy don't have to compete with each other.
The APA recommends developmentally appropriate boundaries around social media alongside education and coaching that help young people develop social media literacy. American Psychological Association
Eventually, students leave school, where teachers and school policies won't always be there to establish boundaries for them.
At some point, young people have to learn to ask themselves: Why am I picking up my phone?
Use it for what they intended to do, and put it back down.
That's why we believe the goal of a phone-free school shouldn't simply be compliance for six hours a day.
It's an opportunity to create an environment where students can experience what it feels like when technology stops constantly competing for their attention, while gradually developing the skills to navigate that technology themselves.
The next generation of phone-free schools may be more intentional, not simply more restrictive
Schools shouldn't have to choose between unrestricted phones and phones that are completely unusable.
There is a meaningful middle ground: Strong boundaries around distraction.
That means:
- Clear expectations about when phones should be away.
- Thoughtful exceptions for health, accessibility, communication and learning.
- Opportunities for students to develop healthier habits around technology over time.
That doesn't mean every school should allow every educational app.
Different communities will draw the line differently. A tool that's useful in one school may be unnecessary in another.
That's exactly the point. Technology policy should serve the learning environment, not the other way around.
We shouldn't be asking only how much time young people spend on screens.
We should also be asking what they're doing there, what that technology is asking of their attention and whether it serves the purpose of the moment.
At home, that might mean recognizing the difference between a 30-minute FaceTime call that connects a child with someone they love and 30 minutes of scrolling that displaced something they intended to do.
At school, it might mean recognizing the difference between opening Desmos to solve an equation and opening a Tiktok algorithmic feed during algebra.
Same device. Different purpose. Different experience.
Phone-free schools give us an opportunity to teach that distinction.
Remove the distraction. Preserve the utility. Build the habit.
Exploring alternatives to phone pouches? Compare the costs, flexibility, and implementation considerations in our guide to The Commons vs. phone pouches.
Research & Resources
For readers who want to dig deeper into the research behind this piece:
- JAMA Pediatrics (2025): Adolescent Smartphone Use During School Hours — objective/passive sensing research on how adolescents use smartphones during the school day. JAMA Network
Read the study - JAMA Network Open (2025): Smartphone Engagement During School Hours Among US Youths — additional objective research on school-day smartphone engagement. DOI
Read the study - American Academy of Pediatrics (2026): Digital Ecosystems, Children, and Adolescents: Technical Report — examines the limits of “screen time” as a standalone concept and the role of algorithms, autoplay, infinite scroll and other digital-design features. American Academy of Pediatrics
Read the AAP technical report - American Psychological Association: Health Advisory on Social Media Use in Adolescence — examines how developmental stage, content, features and context influence adolescents' experiences with social media. American Psychological Association
Read the APA advisory - Oxford Internet Institute: Research on teens, screens and well-being — including large-scale studies finding that broad measures of technology or internet use alone have relatively small or inconsistent relationships with well-being. Oxford Internet Institute
Explore Oxford's Teens and Screens research - National Parents Union (2024): New Poll Shows Parents Are Against Cell Phone Ban in Schools; Raise Alarm Over Negative Effects of Social Media on Children — national parent polling found that 56% supported allowing student phone use at certain times, including teacher-approved academic activities. Read the National Parents Union findings
- National Parents Union (2026): Parents Reject AI Doom Narrative and Want Tech Taught Responsibly in Classrooms — national polling examining parental attitudes toward educational technology, screen-time limits, and responsible technology use.Read the National Parents Union findings